Push: Ensure ref updates are processed in input order
Various places on the client side of the push were creating unordered
maps and sets of ref names, resulting in ReceivePack processing commands
in an order other than what the client provided. This is normally not
problematic for clients, who don't typically care about the order in
which ref updates are applied to the storage layer.
However, it does make it difficult to write deterministic tests of
ReceivePack or hooks whose output depends on the order in which commands
are processed, for example if informational per-ref messages are written
to a sideband.[1]
Add a test that ensures the ordering of commands both internally in
ReceivePack and in the output PushResult.
[1] Real-world example:
https://gerrit-review.googlesource.com/c/gerrit/+/171871/1/javatests/com/google/gerrit/acceptance/git/PushPermissionsIT.java#149
Change-Id: I7f1254b4ebf202d4dcfc8e59d7120427542d0d9e
PushConnectionTest: Increase maxCommandBytes yet again
It was already increased in 61a943e and 661232b but is still not
enough to take into account snapshot versions that are 100 or more
commits ahead of tag, i.e. 4.9.2.201712150930-r.105-gc1d37ca27
Change-Id: Ibeff73adae06b92fe5bb9c5eced9e4c6a08c437c
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
PushConnectionTest: Increase maxCommandBytes again
It was already increased in 61a943e, but that was still not enough to
take into account the length of snapshot versions.
Change-Id: Ib54cec97e97042fe274b87a3a1afa9bb06c8bf19
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
A higher limit is required to account for proper JGit version number
being sent in the UserAgent.
The version string "4.7.0.201704031717-r" is 20 characters, however
the strings used during development are shorter:
- When running from mvn, "4.7.0.qualifier" is used; 15 characters
- When running in Eclipse, "unknown" is used; 7 characters
Change-Id: I9aca2f71389a42fedce305e9078db016869c3d1a
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
Place a configurable upper bound on the amount of command data
received from clients during `git push`. The limit is applied to the
encoded wire protocol format, not the JGit in-memory representation.
This allows clients to flexibly use the limit; shorter reference names
allow for more commands, longer reference names permit fewer commands
per batch.
Based on data gathered from many repositories at $DAY_JOB, the average
reference name is well under 200 bytes when encoded in UTF-8 (the wire
encoding). The new 3 MiB default receive.maxCommandBytes allows about
11,155 references in a single `git push` invocation. A Gerrit Code
Review system with six-digit change numbers could still encode 29,399
references in the 3 MiB maxCommandBytes limit.
Change-Id: I84317d396d25ab1b46820e43ae2b73943646032c
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Matthias Sohn <matthias.sohn@sap.com>
ReceivePack: report protocol parsing failures on channel 3
If the client sent a well-formed enough request to see it wants to use
side-band-64k for status reporting (meaning its a modern client), but
any other command record was somehow invalid (e.g. corrupt SHA-1)
report the parsing exception using channel 3. This allows clients to
see the failure and know the server will not be continuing.
git-core and JGit clients send all commands and then start a sideband
demux before sending the pack. By consuming all commands first we get
the client into a state where it can see and respond to the channel 3
server failure.
This behavior is useful on HTTPS connections when the client is buggy
and sent a corrupt command, but still managed to request side-band-64k
in the first line.
Change-Id: If385b91ceb9f024ccae2d1645caf15bc6b206130
If an application uses PushConnection directly on the native Git wire
protocols JGit should send along the application's expected oldId, not
the advertised value. This allows the remote peer to compare-and-swap
since it was not tested inside JGit.
Discovered when I tried to use a PushConnection (bypassing the
standard PushProcess) and the client blindly overwrote the remote
reference, even though my app had supplied the wrong ObjectId for
the expectedOldObjectId. This was not expected and cost me over an
hour of debugging, plus "corruption" in the remote repository.
By passing along the exact expectedOldObjectId from the app the
remote side can do the check that the application skipped, and
avoid data loss.
Change-Id: Id3920837e6c47100376225bb4dd61fa3e88c64db
This should mirror the behavior of `git push --atomic` where the
client asks the server to apply all-or-nothing. Some JGit servers
already support this based on a custom DFS backend. InMemoryRepository
is extended to support atomic push for unit testing purposes.
Local disk server side support inside of JGit is a more complex animal
due to the excessive amount of file locking required to protect every
reference as a loose reference.
Change-Id: I15083fbe48447678e034afeffb4639572a32f50c