searchForReuse might impact performance in large repositories
The search for reuse phase for *all* the objects scans *all*
the packfiles, looking for the best candidate to serve back to the
client.
This can lead to an expensive operation when the number of
packfiles and objects is high.
Add parameter "pack.searchForReuseTimeout" to limit the time spent
on this search.
Change-Id: I54f5cddb6796fdc93ad9585c2ab4b44854fa6c48
Teach independent negotiation (no pack file) using an option "wait-for-done"
From Git commit 9c1e657a8f:
Currently, the packfile negotiation step within a Git fetch cannot be
done independent of sending the packfile, even though there is at
least one application wherein this is useful - push negotiation.
Therefore, make it possible for this negotiation step to be done
independently.
This feature is for protocol v2 only.
In the protocol, the main hindrance towards independent negotiation is
that the server can unilaterally decide to send the packfile. This is
solved by a "wait-for-done" argument: the server will then wait for
the client to say "done". In practice, the client will never say it;
instead it will cease requests once it is satisfied.
Advertising the server capability option "wait-for-done" is behind the
transport config: uploadpack.advertisewaitfordone, which by default is
false.
Change-Id: I5ebd3e99ad76b8943597216e23ced2ed38eb5224
Move reachability checker generation into the ObjectReader object
Reachability checkers are retrieved from RevWalk and ObjectWalk objects:
* RevWalk.createReachabilityChecker()
* ObjectWalk.createObjectReachabilityChecker()
Since RevWalks and ObjectWalks are themselves directly instantiated
in hundreds of places (e.g. UploadPack...) overriding them in a
consistent way requires overloading 100s of methods, which isn't
feasible. Moving reachability checker generation to a more central
place solves that problem.
The ObjectReader object seems a good place from which to get
reachability checkers, because reachability checkers return
information about relationships between objects. ObjectDatabases
delegate many operations to ObjectReaders, and reachability bitmaps
are attached to ObjectReaders.
The Bitmapped and Pedestrian reachability checker objects were
package private in the org.eclipse.jgit.revwalk package. This change
makes them public and moves them to the
org.eclipse.jgit.internal.revwalk package. Corresponding tests are
also moved.
Motivation:
1) Reachability checking algorithms need to scale. One of the
internal Android repositories has ~2.4 million refs/changes/*
references, causing bad long tail performance in reachability
checks.
2) Reachability check performance is impacted by repository
topography: number of refs, number of objects, amounts of
related vs. unrelated history.
3) Reachability check performance is also affected by per-branch
access (Gerrit branch permissions) since different users can
see different branches.
4) Reachability check performance isn't affected by any state in a
RevWalk or ObjectWalk.
I don't yet know if a single algorithm will work for all cases in #2
and #3. We may need to evolve the ReachabilityChecker interfaces
over time to solve the Gerrit branch permissions case, or use
Gerrit-specific identity information to solve that in an efficient
way.
This change takes the existing public API and moves it to the
ObjectReader/whole repository level, which is where we can do
consistent customizations for #2 and #3. We intend to upstream the
best of whatever works, but anticipate the need for multiple rounds
of experimentation.
Change-Id: I9185feff43551fb387957c436112d5250486833d
Signed-off-by: Terry Parker <tparker@google.com>
Protocol V2: don't log spurious ACKs in UploadPack
UploadPack may log ACKs in protocol V2 that it doesn't send (if it
got a "done" from the client), or may log ACKs twice. That makes
packet log analysis difficult.
Add a new constructor to PacketLineOut to omit all logging from an
instance, and use it in UploadPack.
Change-Id: Ic29ef5f9a05cbcf5f4858a4e1b206ef0e6421c65
Signed-off-by: Thomas Wolf <thomas.wolf@paranor.ch>
Make all transports request protocol V2 when fetching. Depending on
the transport, set the GIT_PROTOCOL environment variable (file and
ssh), pass the Git-Protocol header (http), or set the hidden
"\0version=2\0" (git anon). We'll fall back to V0 if the server
doesn't reply with a version 2 answer.
A user can control which protocol the client requests via the git
config protocol.version; if not set, JGit requests protocol V2 for
fetching. Pushing always uses protocol V0 still.
In the API, there is only a new Transport.openFetch() version that
takes a collection of RefSpecs plus additional patterns to construct
the Ref prefixes for the "ls-refs" command in protocol V2. If none
are given, the server will still advertise all refs, even in protocol
V2.
BasePackConnection.readAdvertisedRefs() handles falling back to
protocol V0. It newly returns true if V0 was used and the advertised
refs were read, and false if V2 is used and an explicit "ls-refs" is
needed. (This can't be done transparently inside readAdvertisedRefs()
because a "stateless RPC" transport like TransportHttp may need to
open a new connection for writing.)
BasePackFetchConnection implements the changes needed for the protocol
V2 "fetch" command (stateless protocol, simplified ACK handling,
delimiters, section headers).
In TransportHttp, change readSmartHeaders() to also recognize the
"version 2" packet line as a valid smart server indication.
Adapt tests, and run all the HTTP tests not only with both HTTP
connection factories (JDK and Apache HttpClient) but also with both
protocol V0 and V2. The SSH tests are much slower and much more
focused on the SSH protocol and SSH key handling. Factor out two
very simple cloning and pulling tests and make those run with
protocol V2.
Bug: 553083
Change-Id: I357c7f5daa7efb2872f1c64ee6f6d54229031ae1
Signed-off-by: Thomas Wolf <thomas.wolf@paranor.ch>
Revert "Client-side protocol V2 support for fetching"
This reverts commit f802f06e7f.
I had misunderstood how protocol V2 works. This implementation only
works if the negotiation during fetch is done in one round.
Fixing this is substantial work in BasePackFetchConnection. Basically
I think I'd have to change back negotiate to the V0 version, and have
a doFetch() that does
if protocol V2
doFetchV2()
else
doFetchV0()
with doFetchV0 the old code, and doFetchV2 completely new.
Plus there would need to be a HTTP test case requiring several
negotiation rounds.
This is a couple of days work at least, and I don't know when I will
have the time to revisit this. So although the rest of the code is
fine I prefer to back this out completely and not leave a only half
working implementation in the code for an indeterminate time.
Bug: 553083
Change-Id: Icbbbb09882b3b83f9897deac4a06d5f8dc99d84e
Signed-off-by: Thomas Wolf <thomas.wolf@paranor.ch>
Make all transports request protocol V2 when fetching. Depending on
the transport, set the GIT_PROTOCOL environment variable (file and
ssh), pass the Git-Protocol header (http), or set the hidden
"\0version=2\0" (git anon). We'll fall back to V0 if the server
doesn't reply with a version 2 answer.
A user can control which protocol the client requests via the git
config protocol.version; if not set, JGit requests protocol V2 for
fetching. Pushing always uses protocol V0 still.
In the API, there is only a new Transport.openFetch() version that
takes a collection of RefSpecs plus additional patterns to construct
the Ref prefixes for the "ls-refs" command in protocol V2. If none
are given, the server will still advertise all refs, even in protocol
V2.
BasePackConnection.readAdvertisedRefs() handles falling back to
protocol V0. It newly returns true if V0 was used and the advertised
refs were read, and false if V2 is used and an explicit "ls-refs" is
needed. (This can't be done transparently inside readAdvertisedRefs()
because a "stateless RPC" transport like TransportHttp may need to
open a new connection for writing.)
BasePackFetchConnection implements the changes needed for the protocol
V2 "fetch" command (simplified ACK handling, delimiters, section
headers).
In TransportHttp, change readSmartHeaders() to also recognize the
"version 2" packet line as a valid smart server indication.
Adapt tests, and run all the HTTP tests not only with both HTTP
connection factories (JDK and Apache HttpClient) but also with both
protocol V0 and V2. Do the same for the SSH transport tests.
Bug: 553083
Change-Id: Ice9866aa78020f5ca8f397cde84dc224bf5d41b4
Signed-off-by: Thomas Wolf <thomas.wolf@paranor.ch>
Signed-off-by: Matthias Sohn <matthias.sohn@sap.com>
Reason why this change is needed:
Currently the durations of fetch events are computed by
registering time instants with System.currentTimeMillis()
and calculating the differences with simple minus operation,
but multiple sources suggest that the best practice is to use
the Java 8 Duration and Instant objects.
What this patch does:
Get time measurements with Instant.now() instead of
System.currentTimeMillis() and calculate the duration of fetch
events (Reachability checks and Negotiation) using
Duration.between().toMillis().
Signed-off-by: Alexa Panfil <alexapizza@google.com>
Change-Id: I573a0a0562070083cf5a5a196d9710f69a7fa587
Reason why this change is needed:
Getting this metric will help estimate how much time will be saved once
the reachability checks get optimized
What this patch does:
Measure time spent by requestValidator.checkWants() in parseWants() and save
it in an instance of PackStatistics.Accumulator.
Signed-off-by: Alexa Panfil <alexapizza@google.com>
Change-Id: Id7fe4016f96549d9511a2c24052dad93cfbb31a4
Reason why this change is needed:
Getting this metric will help estimate how much time is spent
on negotiation in fetch V2.
What this patch does:
Measure time spent on negotiation rounds in UploadPack.fetchV2()
and save it in an instance of PackStatistics.Accumulator.
This is the same way the statistics are already gathered for
protocol V0/V1.
Change-Id: I14e55dd6ff743cb0b21b4953b533269ef069abb1
UploadPack: Use more relevant refs first in object reachability check
The bitmap-bassed object reachability checker, tries to find the objects
in the first starter, then adding the second starter... and so on. This
rewards passing the most popular refs first.
Order the refs with heads first, then tags, then others (e.g. changes)
for the object reachability checker. Using streams, delay also the
resolution of the ref to RevObject until necessary.
Change-Id: I9414b76754d7c0ffee1e2eeed6939895c8e92cbe
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
UploadPack: Refactor to generalize the object reachability checks
ObjectWalk#createObjectReachabilityChecker() returns the best
implementation for the repo. UploadPack can use the interface and fold
the with/without commits cases in one code path.
Change-Id: I857c11735d1d8e36c3ed8185ff11de8a62e86540
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
Extract ObjectReachabilityChecker interface from the walk-based
implementation, to add a bitmapped based implementation later.
Refactor the test case to use it for both implementations.
Change-Id: Iaac7c6b037723811956ac22625f27d3b4d742139
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
Preparing the code to optimize the bitmap-based object reachability
checker. We are mirroring first the commit reachability checker
structure (interface + 2 implementations).
Move the walk-base reachability checker to its own class.
This class is public at the moment. Later ObjectWalk will return an
interface and this implementation will be package-private.
Change-Id: Ifac70094e1af137291c3607d95e689992f814b26
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
UploadPack: Clear advertised ref map after negotiation
After negotiation phase of a fetch, the advertised ref map is no longer used and
can be safely cleared. For >1GiB repos object selection and packfile writing may
take 10s of minutes. For the chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src repo, this
advertised ref map is >400MiB. Returning this memory to the Java heap is a major
scalability win.
Change-Id: I00d453c5ef47630c21f199e333e1cfcf47b7e92a
Signed-off-by: Minh Thai <mthai@google.com>
Move array designators from the variable to the type
As reported by Sonar Lint:
Array designators should always be located on the type for better code
readability. Otherwise, developers must look both at the type and the
variable name to know whether or not a variable is an array.
Change-Id: If6b41fed3483d0992d402d8680552ab4bef89ffb
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
checkNotAdvertisedWants: Be lazy converting Ref to RevCommit
The ref points to an ObjectId that then is translated into a RevCommit.
This translation can be costly and with the incremental reachability
check is probably not needed for most of the elements.
Delay the translation from ObjectId to RevCommit to when it is needed.
Use Streams, that have the laziness built-in, all the way from Ref to
RevCommit.
This should reduce the latency for reachability checks over big sets of
references.
Change-Id: I28693087321b2beff3eaa1f3d2e7840ab0eedc6d
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
ReachabilityChecker: Receive a Stream instead of a Collection
Preparatory change. Converting ObjectIds to RevCommits is potentially
expensive and in the incremental reachability check, it is probably not
required for all elements in the collection.
Pass a Stream to the reachability checker. In the follow up we make
the conversion from ObjectId to RevCommit in the stream (i.e. on
demand). This should reduce the latency of reachability checks over big
sets of references.
Change-Id: I9f310e331de5b0bf8de34143bd7dcd34316d2fba
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
UploadPack: Prioritize references for non-advertised wants checks
UploadPack needs to check if object ids that weren't advertised before
are reachable from the references visible to the user. In the
bitmap-based reachability check, this is done incrementally: checking
against one reference, if anything remaining adding a second and so on.
It is more efficient to check first more common references (e.g. refs/heads/*)
Sort the references for the reachability checker. This should solve the
connectivity earlier and require less bitmap creation and less memory.
Change-Id: I48ac10d71e29fab2d346479802401eaea4aacb5c
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
The flag enabling sideband-all is used in two places: in UploadPack
for advertisement and in the protocol parser to read it from the
request.
This leds to problems in distributed deployments where the two requests of
a fetch can go to different servers with different configurations.
Use the existing allowsidebandall to accept the sideband-all request
(and respond to it) and introduce a new "advertisesidebandall" to toggle
the advertising of the feature.
Change-Id: I892d541bc3f321606c89bad1d333b079dce6b5fa
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
UploadPack: Create a method that propagates an exception as-is
Exception handling can be isolated from UploadPack. This makes it
possible to make the exception handler pluggable.
Change-Id: Ieebbd6711963c7f2e47a98783b4ad815793721c7
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
UploadPack: Consolidate the sideband handling code to one place
This consolidates the sideband stream creation code and the error
handling code for the sideband-allowed part in the Git protocol to one
place.
Change-Id: I0e3e94564f50d1be32006f9d8bcd1ef1ce6bf07e
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
ErrorWriter writes an error message to the user. The implementation is
swapped once it detects that the client supports sideband. By default it
uses the protocol level ERR packet, which was introduced recently.
In total the error output is done in two different places;
UploadPack#upload and UploadPack#sendPack. These will be consolidated in
the next change.
Change-Id: Ia8d72e31170bbeafc8ffa8ddb92702196af8a587
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
These warnings were missed to address in a0048208 which introduced them.
Change-Id: Ia2d15fdce72c10378d020682b80fe7fc548c0d4c
Signed-off-by: Matthias Sohn <matthias.sohn@sap.com>
UploadPack: support custom packfile-to-URI mapping
Teach UploadPack to take a provider of URIs corresponding to cached
packs. When fetching, if the client supports the packfile-uri feature,
and if such a cached pack were to be streamed, instead send the
corresponding URI.
This packfile-uri feature is implemented in the jt/fetch-cdn-offload
branch of Git. There is interest in this feature [1], but it is not yet
merged.
[1] https://public-inbox.org/git/cover.1552073690.git.jonathantanmy@google.com/
Change-Id: I9a32dae131c9c56ad2ff4a8a9638ae3b5e44dc15
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
In a subsequent patch, in some cases, PackWriter#writePack will be
responsible for both the "packfile-uris" and "packfile" sections,
meaning that (in these cases) it must write the "packfile" section
header itself.
In preparation for that patch, move the writing of the "packfile"
section header closer to the invocation of PackWriter#writePack when the
entire fetch response is configured to use the sideband. This means that
"packfile" is written *after* objects are counted (and progress messages
sent to the client in sideband 2) when the "sideband-all" feature is
used (whether "packfile-uris" is used or not), and written *before*
objects are counted otherwise.
Having code to write "packfile" in two places is unfortunate but
necessary. When "sideband-all" is not used, object counting has to
happen after "packfile" is written, because "packfile" activates the
sideband that allows counting progress to be transmitted. When
"packfile-uris" is used, object counting has to happen before "packfile"
is written, because object counting determines whether to send
"packfile-uris" or "packfile". When "sideband-all" is used but
"packfile-uris" is not used, either way works; this commit uses
"packfile-uris" behavior in this case.
Also make the naming of the sideband-activating methods in PacketLineOut
more consistent.
Change-Id: Ifbfd26cc26af10c41b77758168833702d6983df1
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
A caller cannot install a second hook in the UploadPack without
overwriting whatever is already there.
Offer a method to get the current protocol v2 hook, so it can be chained
with new hooks.
Change-Id: Icb06f94ec52b8c8714f509b5b8622d6db42960fb
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
Allow the client to specify "sideband-all" in a fetch v2 request,
indicating that the whole response is to be multiplexed (with a sideband
indicator on every non-flush and non-delim pkt) instead of only the
packfile being multiplexed. This allows, for example, progress messages
to be sent at any point in the response.
This implements the "sideband-all" feature documented in
Documentation/technical/protocol-v2.txt in Git.
Change-Id: I3e7f21c88ff0982b1b7ebb09c9ad6c742c4483c8
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
It is difficult to track what's happening with the pckOut instance
field, so replace it with a local variable in #upload instead.
Change-Id: Ibd9225b28334b7133eccdc6d82b26fc96cbde299
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
Move ServiceMayNotContinueException handling code from sendPack
All other exceptions are handled in a wrapped sendPack method.
Consolidate the error handling code.
Change-Id: Ieac0ce64960534d009d1e6b025130b021b744794
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
By doing this, exceptions thrown by sendPack are also covered by the
same code.
Change-Id: I3509f2d832af1410f307e931577e4d07e32b014e
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
When another exception is thrown while handling another exception, that
exception can be attached to the original exception since Java 7
(Throwable#getSuppressed). Attach the secondary exception to the
original exception instead of throwing it away.
Change-Id: Ia093b8207714f2638e0343bc45a83d4342947505
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
If a client clones with "--filter=blob:none", the checkout that "git
clone" automatically does causes the client to fetch all blobs at HEAD.
When fetching from a non-bitmapped repository, this will fail if an
object walk is ever needed, because JGit currently rejects such requests
- see the commit message of d3021788d2 ("Use bitmaps for non-commit
reachability checks", 2017-11-10) for more information.
Rejecting such requests in the absence of bitmaps is probably
overzealous: it is true that the server would prefer to have bitmaps in
this case, but there might be a small proportion of repos (for example,
very small repos or newly created ones) that do not have bitmaps, yet
the server would still like to have partial clones for them.
So, allow such requests, performing the object walk reachability check
if necessary. Limit this to servers with "uploadpack.allowFilter"
configured, so that servers wanting to support partial clone have this
functionality, and servers that do not support partial clone do not have
to pay the object walk reachability check cost.
Change-Id: I51964bafec68696a799625d627615b4f45ddbbbf
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
When cloning repository with --single-branch option, tag chains are not
packed and pack file is broken in some cases.
Typical test-case:
git tag -a test_tag <commit-id>
git tag -a test_prev_tag test_tag
git tag -d test_tag
git clone --single-branch <repository>
fatal: did not receive expected object <test_tag_id>
The reason for that is missing object for original test_tag reference,
which was deleted.
Problem description:
When pack-objects is given --include-tag, it peels each tag reference
down to a commit. If the commit is prepared to be packed, we we have to
include such tag too. The problem is when the tag points to through some
chain of other tag to commit. Then, the inner tags are not added leading
to broken pack.
Fix:
When going to commit, we have to check and add any of the tags on the
way (if they were not selected, which may happen with --single-branch
option).
Change-Id: I1682d4a2c52d674f90a1b021e0f6c3524c5ce5bc
Signed-off-by: Pavel Flaška <Pavel.Flaska@gmail.com>
Signed-off-by: Matthias Sohn <matthias.sohn@sap.com>
Replace trivial reference comparison of PacketLineIn.{DELIM,END}
Replace reference comparisons of PacketLineIn's DELIM and END strings
with usage of the helper methods isDelimiter() and isEnd().
Change-Id: I52dcfc4ee9097f1bd6970601c716701847d9eebd
Signed-off-by: David Pursehouse <david.pursehouse@gmail.com>
Every caller would need to check if bitmaps are available in the repo to
instantiate a reachability checker.
Offer a method to create the reachability checker in the walk: the
caller has already a walk over the repo, and the walk has all the
information required.
This allows us to make the implementation classes package-private.
Change-Id: I355e47486fcd9d55baa7cb5700ec08dcc230eea5
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
In 7b96bd812e ("UploadPack: Use reachability checker to validate
non-advertised wants", 2019-05-16), a "walk.setRetainBody(false);"
statement was inadvertently deleted. (An earlier version of this commit
had this line in another part of the code and a review comment suggested
to move it back here; the line was then deleted from the other part of
the code but not readded.) Restore this line.
Change-Id: I96ff6106ba9e4eef429388c83e898b3363295f69
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Tan <jonathantanmy@google.com>
UploadPack: Use reachability checker to validate non-advertised wants
In "Reachable commit" request validators, we need to check that a "want"
in the request, that hasn't been advertised, is reachable from the refs
visible to the user.
Current code has intermixed the translation of ObjectIds to RevCommits
(and its error handling) with the actual walk, with the delegation to
bitmaps in restricted circunstances.
Refactor the code to make it "flatter" and more readable. Move ObjectIds
to RevCommits translation to its own functions. Use the reachability
checker instead of a newly defined walk.
Before the non-advertised wants were validated with bitmaps only if any
"want" refered to an non-commit. Now they will be validated with bitmaps
also if the "wants" refer all to commits.
Change-Id: Ib925a48cde89672b07a88bba4e24d0457546baff
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
This is used when fetching, and in particular to populate a partial
clone or a virtual file system cache as the user navigates. With this,
a client can pre-fetch a few directories deeper than only the current
directory.
depth:0 will omit all trees, and is useful if you only want to fetch
the commits of a repository, or fetch just a single tree or blob object.
depth:1 will fetch only the root tree of all commits fetched. depth:2
will fetch the root tree and all blobs and tree objects directly
referenced from it. depth:3 gets one more level, and so on. depth:#
will not filter a blob or tree that is explicitly marked wanted.
Bitmaps are disabled when this filter is used.
This implementation is quite slow because it iterates over all omitted
objects rather than skipping them. This will be addressed in follow-up
commits.
Change-Id: Ic312fee22d60e32cfcad59da56980e90ae2cae6a
Signed-off-by: Matthew DeVore <matvore@gmail.com>
Expose and pass around the FilterSpec object rather than the raw blob limit
Use the FilterSpec object so that less code has to know about the make-up of
FilterSpecs. When fields are added to FilterSpec, these pieces of code won't
need updating again.
Change-Id: I2b9e59a9926ff112faf62a3fa2d33c961a1779e5
Signed-off-by: Matthew DeVore <matvore@gmail.com>
This increases type-safety and is ground work for support of the
"tree:<depth>" filter.
Change-Id: Id19eacdcdaddb9132064c642f6d554b1060efe9f
Signed-off-by: Matthew DeVore <matvore@gmail.com>
HashMap<String, Ref> has a memory overhead for refs. Use RefMap.
Change-Id: I3fb4616135dacf687cc3bc2b473effc66ccef5e6
Signed-off-by: Masaya Suzuki <masayasuzuki@google.com>
BaseReceive/UploadPack: Stop using deprecated RefAdvertiser.send(Map)
RefAdvertiser.send(Map<String, Ref>) is deprecated in favour of
RefAdvertiser.send(Collection<Ref>). Subclasses that need to override
the "send" method need to override also the deprecated version, because
it is still invoked by BaseReceivePack and UploadPack.
Remove the last usages of the deprecated method.
Change-Id: I7eba426970251f78801ddf96b87a65d1baaebdcf
Signed-off-by: Ivan Frade <ifrade@google.com>
UploadPack: Do not retain commit body when checking wants
The commit body contains the commit message, which is not needed for
reachability checks.
Change-Id: Ie209c3b3f022579942f05b8b5d0625ce26400a5d
Signed-off-by: Jonathan Nieder <jrn@google.com>
Fabio Ponciroli
Ronald Bhuleskar
Terry Parker
Thomas Wolf
David Ostrovsky
Alexa Panfil
Ivan Frade
Minh Thai
David Pursehouse
Matthias Sohn
Masaya Suzuki
Jonathan Tan
Pavel Flaška
Matthew DeVore
Carsten Hammer
Jonathan Nieder